The Mets’ gains are pretty obvious, especially if you accept projections of Cabrera rebounding in 2014, whether Baseball Prospectus’ .734 OPS, Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS (.736 OPS, 17 home runs) or the Bill James Handbook’s projecting a .746 OPS. That’s a 100-point jump from what’s generally expected from incumbent Ruben Tejada at the plate. Like Cabrera (minus-16 in BIS’ plus-minus last year), Tejada’s defense wasn’t an asset last year (rating minus-9 in almost a third of a season); unlike Cabrera, there’s no past track record to suggest that he can do better. And why Duda and not Ike Davis? Well, if you’re drinking the Kool-Aid that says 90 wins is possible for this team now, I have to believe Davis’ .954 OPS in the second half last year is a big part of the reason. And trading for Cabrera means you’re drinking pretty deeply from that pitcher of Kool-Aid.
Why does this work for the Indians? Because it gives them help now and upside. Starting with the least valuable player first, Duda would give Cleveland a lefty bat to mix in at first, DH and the outfield, another moving part with platoon punch to fit within Terry Francona‘s lineup-card shifts. Duda’s career numbers against right-handers (.255/.356/.456) will come in handy, especially if David Murphy‘s awful 2013 season (.656 OPS) was his career’s death rattle, leaving the Tribe without a good answer for lefty at-bats at first or in right.
Read the whole article here.
I hate moving that many players in a trade for one player. However, I don’t have problem moving Duda or Fulmer given our pitching depth in the minors. Including Flores too scares me. I gotta let this one simmer.