Is Delgado The Most Logical Choice At First Base?

An article by posted on November 29, 2009

Last week, Bart Hubbuch of the NY Post told me that the Mets are not looking to block the arrival of first base prospect Ike Davis because they view him as an All Star first baseman waiting in the wings. Judging by what we’ve seen and heard from several scouts and MLB executives, maybe the hype on Davis is somewhat justified. I sincerely hope it is, although I personally would like to see Davis continue his hot hitting in Buffalo before I will start heaping praise on him. It seems that AAA has been the place where all Mets prospects and phenoms go to die.

I also have been told by someone who is very familiar with the San Diego Padres thinking, that Adrian Gonzalez will not be traded and that somehow the Padres will find a way to get some sort of extension done with him.

The Brewers have repeatedly said that Prince Fielder is not on the block and that he never has been regardless of what the rumor mongers have put out.

So now that we’ve cleared the clutter a little bit, and have an understanding that the Mets’ plant to anoint Ike Davis as their first baseman in 2011, lets reconsider the plan at first base for the 2010 season.

We are faced with three options.

Stick with Daniel Murphy as the everyday first baseman for one more season.

Find a right handed hitting first baseman to platoon with Daniel Murphy. (The Mets have already warmed up to this idea.)

Sign a full time first baseman off the free agent heap that includes Adam La Roche and Nick Johnson.

Re-sign first baseman Carlos Delgado to an incentive laden deal.

See anything you like?

 

My Thoughts…

I am still not convinced that Daniel Murphy can takeover as the everyday first baseman, especially if the Mets don’t sign a big homerun bat for leftfield.

I’m not entirely opposed to finding a right handed platoon partner , but the good ones still view themselves as everyday players, which leave the likes of Rich Aurilia and Kevin Millar as the best options that won’t break the bank. Troy Glaus is also available, but he would be far more costly.

When you look at Nick Johnson and Adam La Roche head to head, the former Brave seems like the better fit and the one with more power, but with Ike Davis waiting in the wings, would either of them settle for anything less than a 3 or 4-year deal?

As much as it irks me to say it, Carlos Delgado seems like the most logical choice. Of all the options, Delgado would easilyy out-homer and out-slug any of them over the course of a full season. The risk you take though, is whether or not you’ll get a full season out of Delgado. But it’s because of that risk that you could probably get him for a base salary of $5 million dollars, and he most likely would sign a one-year deal.

Your thoughts?

About the Author ()

I'm a lifelong Mets fan who loves writing and talking about the Amazins' 24/7. From the Miracle in 1969 to the magic of 1986, and even the near misses in '73 and '00, I've experienced it all - the highs and the lows. I started Mets Merized Online in 2005 to feed my addiction and interact with other passionate Met fans like you. Follow me on Twitter @metsmerized.

Comments are closed.