Earlier in October, we lamented having to start grading the 2025 Mets after an abrupt end. The 2025 season deserved an immediate and slightly emotional analysis of the disappointment that was the past season. We decided the grades of players’ performances couldn’t soften with time. With grades given, here is every report card for the 2025 New York Mets.
Onward, to free agent profiles and 2026!
Sam Navarro-Imagn Images
Offense’s Grades
- Juan Soto: A-
- Francisco Lindor: B+
- Pete Alonso: A
- Brandon Nimmo: B
- Mark Vientos: D+
- Jeff McNeil: C+
- Francisco Alvarez: B-
- Luisangel Acuña: D
- Brett Baty: B
- Starling Marte: C
- Luis Torrens: B-
- Tyrone Taylor: C
- Ronny Mauricio: D
- Cedric Mullins: F
Benny Sieu-Imagn Images
Pitching Grades
- David Peterson: B-
- Kodai Senga: C
- Sean Manaea: D
- Edwin Diaz: A+
- Clay Holmes: B
- Griffin Canning: B
- Brooks Raley: A-
- Tylor Megill: C
- Huascar Brazobán: C
- Frankie Montas: F
- Jonah Tong: C+
- Nolan McLean: A+
- Brandon Sproat: B
- Tyler Rogers: B
- Ryne Stanek: D
- Ryan Helsley: D
- Gregory Soto: C-
- The Shuttle Squad (Brandon Waddell, Justin Hagenman, Chris Devenski, Kevin Herget): B+
Sam Navarro-Imagn Images
Front Office/Manager Grades
- David Stearns: C
- Steve Cohen: B
- Carlos Mendoza: C+
- All of the coaches (Antoan Richardson not included): C-
- Antoan Richardson: He gets an A.
