We already told you that the Mets, Blue Jays, Dodgers, Padres and two mystery teams are involved in the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes. The Mets just met with him Monday. Who will he sign with? Will it be the Mets? And what will that contract look like? Here’s what we think.

Photo Credit: Detroit Free Press

Robert Colonna

I am going to be optimistic here and follow the signs that the Mets are going to truly go all out, and Cohen will approve of outbidding by whatever it takes to sign Skubal. Based on reports, the Dodgers will likely look to keep it to around four years and maybe $50-55 million a year.

If the Mets truly want him, I do not think they can just add a year or two to whatever the Dodgers offer. If the Padres or the Jays are involved, they are likely willing to at least go medium term. The Blue Jays did offer Kyle Tucker $350 million after all. The Mets likely have to go to at least eight years, and that AAV will have to start with a five.

So I am going to say that Skubal signs with the Mets at eight years and $400 million.

David Melendi

I think in the end Steve Cohen will top whatever the best offer is from another team. An ace is the most glaring need. I think adding Skubal makes it a successful offseason and missing on him makes the 2027 team tough to sell as a playoff contender. Nine years, $403 million.

Steven Bisig-Imagn Images

Jack Ramsey

I try not to get caught up in “but it’s the Mets”, “the Mets are leverage” when it comes to major free agents. The Dodgers beat the Mets out for Yamamoto and Tucker, but LA’s pursuit of Skubal appears to be very different: there is a clear line in the sand that is clearly short of what Skubal wants by a significant margin.

Skubal seems to want a long-term deal; Mark Feinsand reports that the Dodgers want him on a deal closer to what they landed Tucker on, and the Mets seem to not care as long as it results in Tarik Skubal. The Mets have been categorized as the favorite from the jump and the most financially willing. I’ll place my guess at an eight-year deal worth between $400 million and $450 million. I just don’t see a world in which the Mets do not get this done.

Mathias Altman-Kurosaki

For some reason, I feel more confident that the Mets will get Skubal than I was when they were going after Juan Soto. David Stearns has said his priority is bolstering the starting rotation, and Skubal is far and away the arm on the market. Plus, he doesn’t have a qualifying offer attached to him because he was traded in the middle of the season. The only scary thing about Skubal is his injury history, which may lower his cost ever so slightly. I think the Mets land Skubal on an eight-year contract worth $360 million.

Michelle Ioannou

Steve Cohen won’t let the Mets lose out to the Dodgers again – he can’t, right? Let me be optimistic and believe they’ll get it done. When they do, I  think it’ll be an eight-year contract, somewhere around $400 million.

Johnluke Chaparro

Steve Cohen will not be denied in his pursuit of Tarik Skubal, and knowing the Mets absolutely need an ace to aid in building this team’s push to the next level, my guess is that he’ll sign in Queens and will get eight years, $370 million!