« Meet The Mets, Greet The Mets... | Main Page | 5 Reasons The Mets Will Go To The World Series In 2007 »

How our Mets position players stack up against the best of the NL East

The NYsportsGUY Breakdown - Series 1 of 2

We have all heard about the 2007 Mets and what seems like a wobbly starting pitching rotation to start the season. Yes, I see the glass as half empty, but that is only because I’d rather be astounded than disappointed. But who cares. As long as we score 10 runs a game we could have Chan Ho Park pitch every night and we would still win about 75% of the time. So how do the Metropolitans of New York match up against the Phillies of Philadelphia, Nationals of Washington, Braves of Atlanta, and Marlins of Miami? It will be a most ripping comparison.  Even more triumphant than kicking an oblong ball made of pigskin through a big “H”!

Catcher: Paul Lo Duca Vs. Brian McCann - I love the fact that the Mets have had an Italian catcher since 1998. Although he doesn’t have the offensive capability that his predecessor had, he has exceeded my expectations thus far.  Both LoDuca and McCann are gritty, hardheaded gentleman that generally hit for average. They both enjoyed all-star status in 2006. Lo Duca compares favorably when considering runs, hits, and strikeouts-against. But it ends there as McCann trumps Pauly with 24 homeruns against a meager 5 and a .333 average against a hardly embarrassing .318. McCann also had an on base percentage that is 50 points higher than Dukie. But in my opinion, a catcher’s most important job is to call the game and keep the runners on base honest. Any offensive prowess beyond the mask’s emblematic duties is a plus. Lo Duca’s experience outweighs McCann’s (23 years old) exuberance here. McCann has only thrown out a laughable 22% of runners stealing in his career. Which is especially tough when you play against the likes of Jose R. (your boy), Jimmy Rollins, and Hanley Ramirez close to 60 games a year.

Edge - Pauly Lo Duca

First Base: Carlos Delgado Vs. Ryan Howard - It’s difficult to even attempt to compare Ryan Howard to anyone else. This guy led the major leagues in dingers and ribs in 2006 with 58 and 149. He earned the most valuable player award and you can’t argue that he didn’t deserve it. Carlos D. was no scrub either. Amassing a total of 38 ho’runs and 115 rib eyes. Defensively they are both average at best. Delgado’s age and weight hinders his lateral movement but Howard doesn’t shy away from dessert either.

Edge - Ryan Howard

Second Base: Jose Valentin/Anderson Hernandez Vs. Chase Utley - The reason why I put both Valentin and Hernandez as second baseman is because I firmly believe that Hernandez will finish the season there. I love Valentin, but his time in the major leagues is waning. Anderson has the potential to be an important part of Met teams to come. If Hernandez can show Willie that he can have productive AB’s, then he will be performing 5-4-3 double plays with your boy sooner than later. It is only a matter of time. If you had Hernandez and Valentin jump into each other like the two Stations did in Bill and Ted’s Bogus Journey, (obscure, maybe, ridiculous, maybe) to morph into ultimate Met second baseman then they still wouldn’t be as good as Utley. Which isn’t too big of deal considering he is the best second baseman in baseball. His stats have increased by at least 15% each year. With an average of .309, homerun total of 32, and over 100 R.B.I.’ s to his name in ’06.  Expect his numbers to increase again in ‘07. Hey, at least he doesn’t have an irritating nickname like “Pat the Bat” or “Chipper”

Edge - Chase Utley

Shortstop: Jose Reyes Vs. Hanley Ramirez - Reyes is one of the reasons why so many of us are looking forward to this season. Its no mistake that Jose leads this year’s projected fantasy rankings and will most certainly be in the MVP discussions again (Ranked 7th in last years voting). Putting up such gaudy numbers with league leading 64 five-finger discounts and 122 runs. Face it, if your boy learns to “focus” a little better (Willie’s specific word on how Jose can further improve), then he will realize that every walk is virtually a double. It is possible that he can hone in on 130 SB’s. The single season stolen base record set by Mets coach Ricky Henderson in 1982. Ramirez reminds me of a young Reyes (he is a whopping 6 months younger!) Yes that sounds silly, but Hanley is a 5-tool infielder like Jose. He is coming off a rookie season highlighted by 119 runs, 46 doubles, 59 RBI’s, 51 stolen bases, and a Rookie of Year award. These are impressive numbers but Jose’s glove is better and so are his reggaeton songs.  

Edge - Jose, Jose, Jose…Jooosseeeee……Joooooosseee!

Is there a position player I should have included? Let me know in the comment section!

Check in next week for positions 6-9!

Comments

I really enjoyed the Coming to America reference and appreciated the salute to our two favorite American Historians B&T...but it is ownly fair that I make this observation. There is no "Stations", only "Station". Even though there are two seperate beings, both make up one being which is Station. Nice try. Also, in your next article can you refer to Death from Bogus Journey..."You have sunk my battleship!"

Hey great read!

I would have picked the same players as the best at their position in the NL East.

It was a really close call at catcher, but I think I would have went the same way you did.

Loved the reference to Coming To America.

Looking forward to seeing the centerfield battle.

This is an accurate assessment, but I would just go by the current prices of their baseball cards.

I think from now on since i knonw little about the Mets, I will focus on critiquing your knowledge of Films and your aquerate use of each one throughout the course of the season. Here are some films that I believe will provide you with weeks full of inspiration:
Major League 1 & 2
Ghostbusters 2
Crocodile Dundee-"Ya call that a knife?"
Bull Duhram
SUMMER CATCH
Necessary Roughness
Robocop
Saving Silverman
Little Giants
Anchorman
Coyote Ugly...
Weekend at Bernies 1
Dont tell Mom the Babysitters Dead

Great blog but where's D-Wright & Beltran?

This site is owned and operated by Joseph DeCaro. MetsMerized Online is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, the New York Mets or any media outlet cited. The purpose for this website is for criticism, entertainment and commentary and is protected under the Fair Use Provision of the 1976 Copyright Act.

Copyright "MetsMerized Online" 2005-2008, All Rights Reserved.