21
2013
Updated 2013 Mets Minor League Rotations
Exactly a month ago I rolled out my first pass at preseason projections for our Mets minor league rotations. We now have some more clarity and I found myself having to make several updates to my original projections.
Stocks have risen for pitchers like Rafael Montero and Jake deGrom, while others have seen their values slip a little bit. However, most pitchers stayed exactly where I originally placed them.
I didn’t bother extending this to include the GCL or Kingsport because at that stage of the game it’s a complete crapshoot. I went with six-man rotations and in some cases went seven deep so as not to leave any stones unturned.
Here you go…

Las Vegas 51′s (Triple-A)
Dylan Owen and Chris Schwinden are the odd men out here. Jeremy Hefner, Collin McHugh and Jenrry Mejia will be stretched out and ready for whenever the Mets call. Zack Wheeler won’t be rushed and Shaun Marcum will keep his eventual spot in Mets rotation warm until the Wheeler blows them away in the PCL. Jeurys Familia is looking more and more like a reliever now and even Darin Gorski is beginning to trend in that direction lately.

Binghamton Mets (Double-A)
The Mets have a real numbers problem at starting pitching in the mid to low minors. Too many worthy arms and too few spots to fit them all. I was shocked we didn’t use some of these arms to acquire an outfielder that the team desperately needed. What good is a surplus if you don’t use it to your advantage? I didn’t see a way to fit Greg Peavey in AAA or AA, he could be heading to the pen. Mazzoni will easily front this rotation, but Montero and Pill will each make the jump from St. Lucie and both are worth keeping a close eye on, especially Montero. Goeddel could also start off in Bingo simply because of the numbers crunch in St. Lucie. Huchingson and Germen both need good showings after mediocre results in Lucie where they each made over 20 starts. If they don’t show improvement, both could end up in the bullpen once the real gems in St. Lucie start making their way to Bingo.

St. Lucie Mets (High-A)
Get your tongues back in your mouth. This rotation is absolutely scintillating and the Mets have a lot riding on all of these precious arms. It’s an important year for all of them. I have Mateo skipping right past Savannah and going from Low-A to High-A. Fulmer should have been promoted to Lucie last season along with Montero, but will now get his shot against some more advanced hitters. How he responds to that challenge will tell us if he truly is the real deal. Syndergaard will make his Mets pro debut with Lucie and along with Verrett both could advance quickly to Bingo if Huchingson or Germen don’t cut it. Call it a hunch, but I predict that deGrom will be the first of this group to make it all the way to Triple-A before the season ends and even get a cup of coffee in September.

Savannah Sand Gnats (Single-A)
St. Lucie isn’t the only affiliate bursting at the seams with promising young arms. I’m really high on Robles and Ynoa, but don’t count out Panteliodis and Lara either as both are just one pitch away from becoming more complete starters. But even if that doesn’t work out, both will eventually become effective relievers and each have one plus-pitch.
Brooklyn Cyclones (Low-A SS)
- Steven Matz
- Robert Gsellman
- Miller Diaz
- John Gant
- Matthew Bowman
- Bret Mitchell (if healthy)
- Logan Taylor
This group was the most difficult to assess and has the most likelihood of being totally wrong, but if Matz is healthy I’m certain he’ll get the bump from Kingsport. Gsellman and Diaz are no-brainers to make the squad, but I’m afraid Matthew Koch, Perseo Reyes and Chris Flexen will get left behind. They’re both still young and really should have been in the GCL anyway in 2012 if only we had a GCL team. Matt Bowman didn’t get enough PT at Brooklyn last season and will most likely repeat. I like that one, good sleeper.

Those young Mets arms always get me so excited.
I hope you enjoyed this. If you love the Mets minors and think you can do pieces like this and would like to give it a try, shoot me an email at GetMetsmerized@aol.com. We’re starting to round out our minor league team for the 2013 season and are looking for talent. Our goal at Metsmerized is to always provide our readers with a wide range of original Mets content that you can’t get anywhere else!
About the Author: Joe DeCaro
I'm a lifelong Mets fan who loves writing and talking about the Amazins' 24/7. From the Miracle in 1969 to the magic of 1986, and even the near misses in '73 and '00, I've experienced it all - the highs and the lows. I started Mets Merized Online in 2005 to feed my addiction. Follow me on Twitter @metsmerized.
21 Comments + Add Comment


Recent Comments
- Connor O'Brien: on Reds vs Mets: Harvey Looks For Sixth Win, Hawkins Unavailable Today, Red Hot Byrd Batting Fifth: He could be a good closer. He's...
- Connor O'Brien: on Reds vs Mets: Harvey Looks For Sixth Win, Hawkins Unavailable Today, Red Hot Byrd Batting Fifth: It was only a fun little graphic....
- Christopher: on Reds vs Mets: Harvey Looks For Sixth Win, Hawkins Unavailable Today, Red Hot Byrd Batting Fifth: Parnell has been pretty good. I'd give...
- Mr North Jersey: on Reds vs Mets: Harvey Looks For Sixth Win, Hawkins Unavailable Today, Red Hot Byrd Batting Fifth: Thanks Joe D I will and you...
- Joe D: on Reds vs Mets: Harvey Looks For Sixth Win, Hawkins Unavailable Today, Red Hot Byrd Batting Fifth: Michelle, Thanks for the words of wisdom....

An article by





Nice to see a Stetson Hatter, Jacob deGrom, having success in the Mets system. Looking forward to hopefully seeing him pitch in Daytona against the Cubs.
If not for the elbow injury which cost him 18 months, deGrom may be knocking at the door for an MLB rotation spot this Spring.
Joe, do you think deGrom could start in Binghamtom instead of Germen or Hutchingson or even Pill? He´s a little older and did well last year, so could potentially be pushed.
Dave I struggled hard with that one. I mentioned in the Lucie rotation that deGrom would be the first to AAA and it’s because of three things; 1. His age, 2. His composure, 3. His command.
Yes, he could start in AA, it’s not a stretch, but it really depends on who gets cut and who gets sent to the pen. I have a feeling that for April they will start him in Lucie, but that by the end of the month he could be in Bongo where he probably belongs and needs to be.
Here’s the thing, there won’t be any seven man rotations. They might piggyback a few guys, but nobody is developing pitching every eight days.
I doubt Gorski starts in Vegas since he was mediocre in Bingo; unless he shows a lot this spring or moves directly to the bullpen.
I kind of think the reason these guys weren’t traded was because they’ve mostly achieved success in the lower levels. Their value increases once they’ve had success at least in AA. This time next year, the Mets could have an unbelievable amount of players in mlb’s top 100. They could have like 5 or 6 pitchers alone.
DeGrom, Tapia, Fulmer, Mateo, Robles, Lara, Syndegaard, Lara, and Gnoa can all make that list with continued development. And that’s just the pitchers and doesn’t include any 2013 draftees.
Gorski was very mediocre as a starter as you point out. But one of the coaches told me that he will likely transition to a relief role and that it could happen as soon as right now. As for the 7 pitchers think of it as a depth chart, only five will get slotted but it’s always good to see the entire landscape.
CThomp519 wrote: “I kind of think the reason these guys weren’t traded was because they’ve mostly achieved success in the lower levels. Their value increases once they’ve had success at least in AA. ”
I agree. Don’t forget…..
AA is the biggest jump in baseball & a graveyard for avg fastball pitchers
Hmm. I see things a bit different:
Either Hefner or Laffey will be in the mlb bullpen, I suppse. Can’t see the Mets going without any sort of long reliever.
AAA: Wheeler – Mejia – McHugh – Gorski – Schwinden is my guess. If a 6th SP s needed it’ll be Cohoon or Owen.
Familia & Germen will transition to the bullpen, I suppose.
AA: this will be interesting. Mazzoni is the only lock. With all the buzz, I see Montero in here. Probably Goeddel. Due to his age and looming 40-man decision, DeGrom could be pushed here. Assuming the BMets have a 6-man rotation, Pill & Verrett should round out the staff. Maybe Angel Cuan instead of DeGrom or Montero early on as the lone lefty. Peavey & Hutchigson will be relievers.
Hi A: Syndergaard – Fulmer – Tapia should be locks. I believe Panteleodis will be here as a lefty after his strong finish. As a 40-man roster player, I expect to see Robles here, probably joined by Mateo to form one of the most promising rotations in the entire minors on paper.
Low A: Ynoa & Lara should be locks. I also expect Matz here, if healthy, considering he’s Rule V eligible after the season. Same for Miller Diaz, so he is a good bet to appear here. Matt Koch may project as a reliever but will start initially, I believe. The final spot is anyone’s guess among Cessa, Hillario, Gsellman, Taylor or Gant, imho. With some heading to Brooklyn.
In any case, it’s good to have an interesting prospect projected for almost every rotation spot for these teams. Due to the strong control exhibited by some of these arms and the depth in numbers, I expect to see some being pushed a bit faster than before. Of course, injuries may take care of these ” problems”. In spite of a good pitching development program, I can’t see another almost injury free year like in 2012…
a real interesting thing to monitor is how many of the PSL guys pitch their way up to Bingo this year. Hopefully 2-3 do, since that would mean they obviously wear dealing, but also are now a quick jump to the majors (with the comensurate higher trade bait value too).
some of the number crunch will work itself out naturally if a couple guys get hurt in ST. Hopefully not, since too much talent is not really a bad thing! And odds are, some guys that probably deserve to start will be fighting for innings out of the pen.
I agree about being surprised they did not move a few guys this off season. No clue if the returns just weren’t there, or they are hoping to hang onto the arms through the next level (AA?) where they will be more valuable.
of course, deadline deals are much easier if you have an abundence of players that other teams want. And if not moved then, thee will be no choice but to trade some in the off season or they will lose them for nothing.
so, figure out of this bunch a few guys come up lame, a couple move to the pen (and hopefully shoot to the majors!), and plenty of them force there way up the chain.
finally, my dark horse to be the break-out guy that moves a couple levels quick is Matz.
With all due respect to Mike Antonini and Jefrey Marte, the Mets haven’t traded a real prospect in 4+ years.
And while the slow building process ain’t easy, it’s probably the right call to keep all the chips together until the time to cash in is right – which probably is next winter.
And as long as no legit prospect is blocked, it’s not an issue. So if there’s no rotation room for Peavey or Cuan, so be it…
Agreed. But, next winter can easily start this July if the right player becomes available. Not just thinking of trading for a rental for the stretch run (though it would be fantastic to be in that position!) But even if the Mets are selling, it may be possible to expand a deal to bring a higher end player back.
tough of course to find say a team that needs a SP real bad, but has too many OFs to use them all, but the key is, the more chips you have, the better position you are to take advantage of an opportunity.
DeGrom was a Viola favorite. I heard he even talked Jacob into possibly bringing back the Viola Mustache once he eventually makes the bigs…
I’ll be talking to Jake either Tuesday or Wednesday of next week in an interview for MMO.
Matz, if he could only just stay healthy, could become the best lefty pitcher the Mets have produced in decades… This guy is a beast and throws close to 100 mph as a starter. But, he’s the Reese Havens of their minor league pitchers.
well, Reese had a variety of 1-off injuries, and ow seems to have a chronic back issue.
matz was just a TJ surgery guy that took a while to get all the way back from it, but pretty sure he has not had any other injuries, so no reason to think he is any different than the multitude of other young pitchers that had fine careers after having TJ.
They traded Lindstrom and Heath Bell…that didn’t work out very well.
Joe D,
If Hefner and Laffey are headed for Vegas, then who will be the Mets long-man in the pen?
Hi Harry,
Currently I project the bullpen like this:
CL: Bobby Parnell
SU: Brandon Lyon
RP: Josh Edgin
RP: Scott Atchison
RP: Pedro Feliciano
RP: Greg Burke or LaTroy Hawkins or Elvin Ramirez
http://metsmerizedonline.com/2013/02/projected-mets-opening-day-roster-are-valdespin-and-turner-out.html
Joe, why would you consider Elvin Ramirez in the running but not Familia?
So you don’t expect the Mets to have a long-man in the pen? Isn’t that pretty unorthodox?