It’s Time To Change The Hall Of Fame Voting Process
I’ve read many columns from my colleagues, and was greatly disappointed in those who would not recognize a player on the first ballot, and even worse, those who returned their ballots blank.
As I wrote yesterday, boycotting first timers is an abuse of power. If you truly believe a player merits induction based on his career, then he should be on your ballot the first year.
You can’t legislate whom a voter marks down on his ballot, and history has shown this practice has gone on since the voting began.
It was our own Tom Seaver who appeared on the highest percentage of the ballots when he appeared on 98.84 percent of the ballots cast. In the all-time rankings of the Hall of Fame inductees by percentage: Ty Cobb (4), Babe Ruth and Honus Wagner (tied 11), Willie Mays (14), Ted Williams (18), and Stan Musial (19).
Did you know, Frank Robinson, Joe DiMaggio, Al Kaline, Mickey Mantle, Mel Ott, Yogi Berra, Bob Gibson and Harmon Killebrew didn’t even receive 90 percent of the vote when they first appeared on a ballot?
Did you know, before the voting rules changed, that Lou Gehrig received only 22.6 percent of the vote?
How could any of these players not appear on a voter’s ballot?
If you’re a voter and believe a player is worthy, he should not be omitted based on his first year of eligibility. Frankly, that is an abuse of your voting privileges.
Then there is the issue of the blank ballot. You’re allotted ten votes. Send your message against the steroid users all you want, but don’t penalize a worthy candidate with a blank ballot because it still counts and it impacts the percentages. I find it impossible out of all the candidates a voter can’t find at least one player worthy.
A blank vote is a vote of arrogance.
There are several voting guidelines, but one should never be to dictate how a member votes. I am disappointed in the first-year and blank ballot voters, but don’t believe they should lose the right to vote based on their God-complex.
What changes would I make in the voting process?
- I would have the Hall of Fame voters identified with their choices. Media members can find out easily enough as to whom the voters chose. I think it should be out front and a condition of the voting.
- Blank ballots should be identified and not count against the percentage of ballots cast. This will eliminate the voter who votes against Barry Bonds and in the fallout penalizes Craig Biggio.
- Identify drug users on their plaques and have their names listed with an asterisk in the record books. Tainted players have tainted records. In my thinking, Hank Aaron and Roger Maris have the career and single-season home run records, not Bonds and McGwire. When I refer to Bonds and McGwire, I’ll say “balls hit over the wall,” and not call them home runs.
Baseball is about numbers and history. Bonds, Clemens and Rafael Palmeiro, not to mention Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson, all have careers worthy of induction. We just can’t pretend their careers didn’t exist.
To put a scarlet letter on their careers doesn’t condone their actions, but acknowledges their complete roles in the sport.
About the Author: John Delcos
I am an active member of the BBWAA and have covered Major League Baseball in several capacities for over 20 years, including ten in New York working the Mets' and Yankees' beat. I covered the Baltimore Orioles for eight years and the Cleveland Indians before that. I currently serve as an editor and senior staff writer for Mets Merized Online. Follow me on Twitter @jdelcos.
33 Comments + Add Comment
- philipag: on Scout Says No Way Flores Can Play Any Position But First Base: I didn't think he looked bad at...
- SaltyGary: on Mets and Braves Suspended After Eight Tied 5-5, Will Resume Play Saturday: Well lets see for Ike, he's known...
- kevin: on Mets and Braves Suspended After Eight Tied 5-5, Will Resume Play Saturday: you hit the nail on the head...
- kevin: on Cowgill and Nieuwenhuis Continue to Struggle in Minors: question, when do legares and puello get...
- Metfan Lou: on Mets and Braves Suspended After Eight Tied 5-5, Will Resume Play Saturday: Although I was disgusted at the Hawkins'...
Check Out These Great MLB Links!
Mets Autograph Signings
Mets Fan Apparel
Mets Autographed Baseballs
Baseball Card Supplies
For the best seats and lowest MLB ticket prices, go to PurchaseSeats.com. Get your Mets Tickets now and follow them on the road with Yankees Tickets, Phillies Tickets, Nationals Tickets and Braves Tickets!