Jul
13
2012

Terry Collins: If The People Who See Harvey Say He’s Ready, Bring Him Up

Harvey Hysteria is gripping the Mets fanbase and I think even manager Terry Collins is getting caught up in it as he continues to weigh in daily and leans toward bringing him up with each passing day.

Maybe during an idle moment, Collins had an opportunity to take a gander at Miguel Batista’s and Jeremy Hefner’s starts this season with the Mets? Maybe he didn’t particularly care for his big sniff of reality?

Hefner has a 6.89 ERA in three starts this season for the Mets, while Batista was a little better posting a 1,63 WHIP in four starts. Sobering numbers indeed for a manager who is presiding over a team that’s apparently in a playoff push.

During the All Star Game when Collins was first asked about the possibility of Matt Harvey replacing Dillon Gee in the rotation, he emphatically said Batista would get the start next Wednesday against the Nationals.

A day later, after learning that Gee could be lost for the season, he hedged and left the door open saying there’s a “remote possibility” we could see Matt Harvey get that start next Wednesday.

Then yesterday, he sounded like a man pleading on his hands and knees when he said, “If the people who see him say he’s ready, bring him up. I’m all for it.”

The second half of the season begins tonight for the Mets who are 46-40 and still in the thick of it.

Every game counts.

This may not be the most ideal time to debut one of your blue-chip prospects, but it’s as good a time as any. And how seductive does a Matt Harvey vs. Stephen Strasburg matchup sound to you? Or would you prefer a Batista vs Strasburg matchup instead?

There are those who say winning isn’t everything, the heck with it and leave Harvey at Triple-A where he can continue to fine tune his game until a September call-up when rosters expand. Of course by then, you won’t have to worry about the kid having any added pressure over performing in meaningful games in September.

This is not about Matt Harvey. It’s a question of whether the team wants to put their best players out there and win, or waving the white flag with the likes of Miguel Batista. I say this because ready or not, Harvey still gives the Mets a better chance to win than Batista does. So what’s your pleasure?

What will the Mets do?

Share Button

About the Author: Joe DeCaro

I'm a lifelong Mets fan who loves writing and talking about the Amazins' 24/7. From the Miracle in 1969 to the magic of 1986, and even the near misses in '73 and '00, I've experienced it all - the highs and the lows. I started Mets Merized Online in 2005 to feed my addiction. Follow me on Twitter @metsmerized.

37 Comments + Add Comment

  • Joe D, don’t you know? Hold up on Harvey!! Lol…

    Bring up this kid, this Front office and its leader are very futile at best at making deals etc, we all know they’ll probably bring up crap to help the team as they’ve done in 2 consecutives offseason, instead of bringing batista and that other bum hefner bring up this kid.
    If he does struggle, then we are in the same place we were had we brought up Hefner or batista,worst case we send him down, fix the problem and let him fogure out, if he does good, he may help us form a very good rotation with Dikey, Santana and Niese the rest of the way.
    There’s no clear cut juggernaut offensive teams in the NL so now it’s the time!

    • Alex, I’d like to teach you a little lesson that most people do in fact learn between the ages of say 5-8 years old.

      When you wish to be left alone such as you mentioned in the shoutbox yesterday at 12:56 pm “alex68 Please ignore me ok…”

      You cannot then turn around and talk about that person in any way shape or form if you wish to be left alone.

      If you do not want me to respond to the things you say, then either a) don’t say them or b) don’t say them about me and then act as though you wish to just be left alone.

      It doesn’t work both ways.

      Also, do not comment about what people write if you have not read it yourself. This is a formula that enables ignorance at its best. If you’d like to actually READ what I wrote, then please feel free to comment. However, if you are just going to type things about my posts with no merit to it… you better be ready for a response from me.

      • Someone is Trolling!

      • funny seeing a total fraud ,like you jessup berating someone for their post. You jessup, the person who writes incessantly after always starting your pathetic novellas with the pathetic “I don’y know anything” line. Well, you are right about one thing Jessup.. You know nothing. NOTHING.. And since you know nothing you aren’t one to berate Alex68 for his [posts. At least he knows something.

        • thanks for the reply Amazin. One day you’ll need to fill me in on what I actually said to turn you so sour toward me. I’ve yet to have an interaction with you that would lead me to understand why you constantly attack me after somebody else does.

          The fact remains, I was asked to ignore Alex and less than 24 hours later he’s using a blog I wrote to mock me and then cannot have the backbone to admit he used THE EXACT QUOTE as a shot at me.

          You can defend that all you want, but all it proves is there is an agenda on your end.

          I don’t know you, I don’t hold anything you say against you but I haven’t seen much of anything except personal attacks toward me and others which make me question why you’re here.

      • I Am glad peopel are starting to see you for the phony you are..

        • You mean the same handful of people.

    • Do yourself a favor Jessep, first of all, don’t think too highly of yourself, usually people that accomplish something in life do.
      Second of all, when did i even mention your name!?? you’re a pathetic little weasel who is somehow looking for attention ok, don’t try to bait me as you often do with others, that is the main reason some of us get warnings etc, i do ignore you and your post, i don’t comment on your crap so please make sure you refer to post on anything i say, all i said was hold on on harvey, do you have copyrights to that word or something? again, i do not need to read your crap to know it is ok

  • The Mets don’t need a 5th SP until the 21st so that should give Harvey 3 more starts in AAA before Batista would be scheduled to make his 2nd start. How both parties do in those starts should dictate what the Mets do.

    If Harvey does well and Batista does not, then call him up, if they both do poorly call up Hefner, if they both do well keep using Batista until he does poorly and if Batista does well and Harvey does not, then keep going with him…

  • Go for it. We bought up Ruben Tejada much to early and he has helped the team from day one. Valdespin might be early but he’s here to stay. Ike Davis at the time was brought up early and led the team in HR and RBI in 2010. If the player is as good as advertised he will help the team, if he’s not, we’ll know soon enough and we can go after Cole Hamels after the season.

    • Cole Hamels?? Ewwww, I hate that guy. Are you crazy!

      • He is heading for the cash and the West Coast so no danger.

  • A couple of days ago you said Matt Harvey still needed “more seasoning” and that if he got smacked around you was going to tell everyone “I told you so”. Today “it’s as good a time as any” to call him up. Is this a symptom of Harvey Hysteria? :-P

    I continue to believe the biggest positive for calling him up was Backman’s comments regarding him. If internally the coaches feel he ready then bring him up especially if it’s not a short term basis.

  • Ok new rule here…
    Anytime Collins says what is the plan or comments on a player playing days before he will actually play, know that what he really means is that guy won’t be playing!

    I have to wonder (as this has happened almost everytime there is a need for roster movement) if this “who’s on first i don’t know, no he’s playing 3rd base” routine is really Terry just thinking out loud and being flippant? Or if this is due to the fact we seem to have a Front Office by Committtee who seem to make a decision that changes daily until there is no more time to change your mind and they just go with whoever was last picked to play that game!

    This is not the first time it has happened….
    Torres coming back from injury, Bay being annouced as starter despite the fact he isn’t even with the team yet. Send Ike Down, no Leave him Up, Mejia is a pen arm but maybe he’s a starter etc…etc…

    There sure does appear to be a lot indecision going around upstairs at the mets and I wonder if that same indecision is why they have yet to make a single trade yet despite having a few guys on the roster who are out of options and hurting out Roster flexability.

    They need to start getting on the same page here or we will be screwed!

  • Bring up Harvey and Hefner. Let’s use a 6 man rotation durring the dog days of summer. We’ll need deep outings since our bullpen is so weak. If H n H don’t work out…try something else. Insanity is using the bullpen like we did in April and May.

    • 6.89 ERA as a starter… No Heffy please.

      • I think you can write off the bad start where he gave up all those runs after the rain delay. He did fine in the other ones.

        He’s not the solution, but he’s probably better than Batista who is nothing more than a mop-up guy with a rubber arm at this point

        • Even if you throw that start out his average ERA is somewhere around 5.50+

          Now granted a lot of those appearances are as a reliever not a starter but if you seperate out just the starts he still is above 5.2 in ERA.

          • actually it would be 4.24

            • I want Hefner’s bat. LOL

  • Why is Collins saying all this stuff? This is not his decision to make. Where is the GM and what does he have to say about all of this? I just dont see other managers talking about player promotions the way Collins does. It’s not his damn job. Let him figure out what to do with the team and roster he has.

    • how many other teams do you follow on a daily basis? Can’t compare to the Yankees since their day-to-day moves are meaningless since they will be in the playoffs every single year regardless of what happens…

    • Collins is saying it because he knows that his GM is incompetant. For the kool aide drinkers, too bad. Even the manager knows his boss is over the hill. maybe early stage alzheimers. Maybe he only found success due to Canseco getting his A’s to al ljuyice up.

      • Collins is saying it because he knows that his GM is incompetant. For the kool aide drinkers, too bad. Even the manager knows his boss is over the hill”

        Amazin, Don’t tell that to the people who somehow this GM has done a good job… I mean, two offseason and nothing to show for.. Looking for every little thing that happens to celebrate the pathetic effort from the GM

      • One of the most ridiculous things I’ve heard.

        How can you spin the comment he made that way? All Terry is saying is he wants the best guy he can get. Isn’t that what any manager would say?

        And i love how you will spin what I said to mean that I love Sandy too…

        • Welcome to the wonderful world of MMO. Some people here will always twist things around here to make it appear that way…unfortunately, it’s because they have nothing between the ears.

        • Sigh… the Stalking continues!!!

          • Piss off, troll. You’re not that special.

    • He’s saying exactly what the FO is telling him is the plan and is getting tripped up because they can’t decide on anything and vascilate over every move!

      You can do that in a chess game but not as the GM of a baseball team.
      The game will just pass you by if you do!

      This is what happens when you have too many GM cooks trying to make the soup!
      Everyone thought having three possible GM talents was a good thing….And what has it got us?
      Lack of Direction or Conviction!

    • Because he’s being asked a dozen times a day maybe?

      It is the FO’s call, as you said.
      And it seems to me the reason some of these answers are all over the place is because they just don’t know at the moment. They didn’t count on losing Gee, they probably looked at Harvey coming up in Sep maybe for a few starts.

      Didn’t work out that way so now they’ve got some decisions to make.
      I guess we’ll know when they finally make those decisions.

  • This manager is a joke. I read another article that says its not a “open tryout” up there right now as they’re in the race. On the flip side they also have been saying they want edgin and mejia up there to gauge where they are at before the deadline. A open tryout is exactly what they’re doing up there. If youneed to know how guys are doing you can read reports from Wally and check their stats from the 3 months of playing games. Not to mention terry Collins the day before the break said edgin and mejia are up and down and need to be more consistent before being there then over the break they call up edgin??? Did he show consistency while on the all-break in the backyard at his house??? I don’t see how you can make these comments and be taking serious as a person who has a idea of what your doing. By what terry said today I expect Harvey to make his next start against Washington. If he said he was ready I’d be concerned about them waiting until September

    • All he is saying is he wants the person most likely to help the team win. That’s it…

      • And what was he saying when Bautista was the guy who was going to start?

        You can’t minimize what he’s saying now when what he said is a flip flop from 4 days ago!
        Over the course of one All Star Break we went from Bautista to Harvey and we haven’t even played the first game yet?

        Either terry screwed up or was told the wrong plan and that means the FO flip flopped and can’t decide which says to me Hefner or Schwinden gets the start before the week is out because thats the only name they haven’t mentioned yet!

  • as soon as Gee had to get season ending surgery, they situation changed, and that had a major impact on what decision you would make (as opposed to if he was going to miss 2-3 weeks).

    And adjusting your position as the situation changes is common sense, not “flip flopping”.

    • SO they didn’t flip flop on Harvey being ready over the course of 4 days where no games were played, I don’t even think they played any in the Minors either they too were on thier all star break!

Recent Comments

Need Tickets To The Mets Game?

Check Out These Great MLB Links!

For wholesale prices on New York Mets gifts and equipment, check these stores out!
Mets Autograph Signings
Mets Fan Apparel
Mets Autographed Baseballs
Baseball Card Supplies
Baseball Equipment
For the best seats and lowest MLB ticket prices, go to PurchaseSeats.com. Get your Mets Tickets now and follow them on the road with Yankees Tickets, Phillies Tickets, Nationals Tickets and Braves Tickets!

Photographs From Gordon Donovan

Advertisement

Advertisement

Google+