This week the Yankees captured yet another World Series. Combined with our beloved Mets, the two New York teams have now combined for 29 Championships. In the tradition of Donn Clendenon and Ray Knight, Hideki Matsui was named Series MVP. The Yankees got a memorable HR from A-Rod, much like Al Weis in 69. Johnny Damon stole a game with a brilliant play on the basepaths, similar to J C Martin against the Orioles. The final out was recorded with Yankees closer Mariano Rivera on the mound. We had our closer on the mound for the final out in 86, too. A team from New York, playing its first season in a new stadium, brought home their 44th combined pennant followed days later by a World Series flag…
OK, come on people. I’m trying. Work with me…
I found it ironic that both League Championships were decided just before Halloween. For Mets fans is there anything more frightening and horrifying then a World Series between the Yankees and Phillies? The two teams we hate, despise and loathe the most battling it out on national TV while we Mets fans sat and stared in disbelief. With apologies to Charles Dickens, ‘twas the worst of times, ‘twas the worst of times.
We debated the lesser of two evils, trying to decide which enemy we would rather see lose. If there was ever a time where Bud Selig should have cancelled the World Series, this was as good a time as any. The choice was not easy. It was like someone asking, “Would you rather be poked in the right eye with a sharp object or poked in the left eye with a sharp object?” Either way the end result is going to be painful.
For me I chose to “root” for the Yankees, keeping in mind I have hated that team since childhood. The first words I ever spoke
were ‘Momma,’ ‘Dadda’ and ‘Yankees suck.’ Although I’ve disliked the Yankees longer, I despise the Phillies more. When all is said and done, what the Yankees do really has no effect on us. They are our rivals only in the sports pages. The Phillies, however, are our rivals on the field. For me the choice was somewhat simple: Do I have more loyalty to New York or to a bunch of clubs in a group called ‘The National League?’ And lets be honest. We all KNOW that had the Phillies been victorious, we’d be subjected to Jimmy Rollins boasting about how his club beat yet another team from New York.
To the casual fan or outsider, it’s a very simple connection: The team with the biggest payroll won. This is a nightmare for the likes of Bud Selig and small market teams from coast to coast. However, the Yankees showed us a valuable lesson. It’s not how much you spend but how you spend. We all shook our heads in disgust when The Evil Empire handed over a quarter of a billion dollars for Sabathia and Burnett. Of the 11 post-season wins needed to win it all, those 2 pitchers accounted for 4. However, it was the veteran big game pitcher Andy Pettitte who accounted for 4 more all on his own. Without Pettitte the Yankees don’t win. And without Sabathia and Burnett, they also don’t win.
I think that is something we need to keep in mind as we head into a crucial winter. It seems like the long term future of our team will be decided over the next few months. We have plenty of issues that need to be addressed. In addition to Reyes’ hamstring, we have to replace Delgado’s big bat at 1B. We are concerned with the fact that David Wright hit only 234 after returning from his concussion. We have to do something drastic about the big drop off from Johan to the rest of the staff.
As much as it pains me to say this, perhaps we can learn something from that other team. The key to winning is not just signing the biggest names to the biggest contracts. Instead it’s using the money wisely. The idea is not to build a team of big names, but to build a winner. We have the money. We have the revenue. We have the fan support. We have our own ‘Core Four.’ What we don’t have is a winner. Hopefully, this winter Omar can change that.
So, to the Yankees, I say ‘Thank you.’ Thank you for shutting up Jimmy Rollins. Thank you for bringing the hated Phillies down a bit. Thank you for bringing a championship back to the greatest city in America. However pitchers and catchers report in a little over 3 months. That’s when we can start hating the Yankees again.








I still hate the Braves more than the Phillies. I “rooted” for the Phillies, because I do like the National League but also, I would love that team if they wore our laundry. The Phillies were created the right way with homegrown talent. They are tenacious and gritty and all the things that we are not. If that team wore the New York Mets uniforms, we would talk about how much they resemble the ’86 team.
The Yankees did it the way the Yankees always do. There’s no fun in “rooting” for the team that buys an all-star at every position. Come on, be honest. If Victorino and Utley were Mets, they’d probably be your favorite players.
The Yanks have way more (overpaid) homegrown players than we do. I think we’ve proved that our front office does a terrible job evaluating health and talent. If we want to spend money anywhere this season, I say we take 20 mil and bring in the Marlins scouting staff and the Phoenix Sun’s trainers.
I always enjoy reading your articles, and I respect your choice to root for the Yankees based on the reasons you cited. I too hate the Yankees and always have, but as much as I hate the Phillies, I couldn’t bare to see the Yankees win another title. And though you made a fine attempt at sugar coating it by combining their 27 with the Mets 2 titles, it didnt really make me feel any better. Having to choose the lesser of two evils is always going to have a bad result anyway you cut it.
Kinda funny our similar articles posted haha.
“This week the Yankees captured yet another World Series. Combined with our beloved Mets, the two New York teams have now combined for 29 Championships…. A team from New York, playing its first season in a new stadium, brought home their 44th combined pennant followed days later by a World Series flag…”
Way to go, but why not go all the way?
The New York Mets have won four pennants (2000 • 1986 • 1973 • 1969) and two World Series (1986 • 1969).
The New York Giants won 17 pennants (1954 • 1951 • 1937 • 1936 • 1933 • 1924 • 1923 • 1922 • 1921 • 1917 • 1913 • 1912 • 1911 • 1905 • 1904 • 1889 • 1888 and five World Series (1954 • 1933 • 1922 • 1921• 1905).
The Brooklyn Dodgers won 12 pennants (1956 • 1955 • 1953 • 1952 • 1949 • 1947 • 1941 • 1920 • 1916 • 1900 • 1899 • 1890) and one World Series (1955).
The Yankees have won forty pennants and 27 World Series.
All told, if my arithmetic held up, New York City teams have won 73 pennants and 35 World Series. What a terrific baseball city!
Great article, Tie Dyed.