All Time Mets Fantasy Team – First Base

Ever wanted to figure out what the all time best fantasy team would be comprised solely of New York Mets players based on actual single season stats?

The only eligibility to qualify was that the player had to play the position the majority of the time for the Mets in that season.

Here are twelve of the best seasons for a Mets first baseman ever. 

YR PLAYER AB R H HR RBI AVG OBP SLG SB
1970 D. Clendenon 396 65 114 22 97 .288 .348 .515 4
1980 L. Mazzilli 578 82 162 16 76 .280 .370 .431 41
1984 K. Hernandez 550 83 171 15 94 .311 .409 .449 2
1987 K. Hernandez 587 87 170 18 89 .290 .377 .436 0
1990 D. Magadan 461 74 148 6 72 .328 .417 .457 2
1993 E. Murray 610 77 174 27 100 .285 .325 .467 2
1995 R. Brogna 495 72 143 22 76 .289 .342 .485 0
1997 J. Olerud 524 90 154 22 102 .294 .400 .489 0
1998 J. Olerud 557 91 197 22 93 .354 .447 .551 2
1999 J. Olerud 581 107 173 19 96 .298 .427 .463 3
2006 C. Delgado 524 89 139 38 114 .265 .361 .548 0
2008 C. Delgado 598 96 162 38 115 .271 .353 .518 1

I added Clendenon to the list so we could have at least one player represent the first decade in the franchise’s history. In truth though, the Mets have had some of the worst seasons I have ever seen from a first baseman. It was either feast or famine, and the above is surely the feast.

I added Lee Mazzilli only because that was a lofty number of stolen bases for a guy who played first base. His other numbers were not altogether different from Keith Hernandez in 1987.

Statistically, John Olerud may have had the best season in Mets history when he batted .354 in 1998. Although the Mets never won a World Series with Olerud, he may just be the best first baseman the Mets have ever had. It’s a shame they didn’t resign him in 2000 and opted for Todd Zeile instead. Maybe the Mets would have beaten the Yankees that year if they had Olerud batting third.

It’s interesting to note that Carlos Delgado holds his own in Mets history at the position. Everyone immediately thinks Keith Hernandez when the conversation comes up, and of course rightfully so. But statistically, his best season may not even be in the top five of the all time best seasons at first base.

Next up, second base.

About Joe D 7855 Articles
I'm a lifelong Mets fan who loves writing and talking about the Amazins' 24/7. From the Miracle in 1969 to the magic of 1986, and even the near misses in '73, '00 and '15, I've experienced it all - the highs and the lows. I started Mets Merized Online in 2005 to feed my addiction and interact with other passionate Met fans like you. Follow me on Twitter @metsmerized.